The root Certificate Authority that signed the target server's SSL certificate is not present in ServiceNow's Java truststore, which is the most common scenario for custom or internal CAs. (high likelihood)
The target server is presenting an incomplete certificate chain that doesn't include intermediate certificates needed to establish trust back to a known root CA. (high likelihood)
ServiceNow's Java truststore has been modified or corrupted, removing standard root CAs that should be trusted by default. (medium likelihood)
The target server is using a self-signed certificate that hasn't been explicitly imported into ServiceNow's truststore as a trusted certificate. (medium likelihood)
Certificate validation is being enforced by system property changes when it was previously bypassed, revealing existing trust issues. (low likelihood)